Major video game review platform Metacritic announces a big change to user reviews in order to combat review bombing. The change comes afterThe Last of Us 2was review bombedby Metacritic users who gave the game a score of 3.4 out of 10 compared to the 95 out of 100 that it received from critics.
Today,Metacriticofficially announced that it would be making users wait 36 hours before posting a review about a game. This waiting period will “ensure our gamers have time to play these games before writing their reviews,” said a Metacritic spokesperson, who added that the change “was based on data-driven research and with the input of critics and industry experts.” The spokesperson also stated that the 36-hour waiting period wasn’t made “in light of any particular game.”
RELATED:Valve Introduces Tool to Combat Review Bombing
The Last of Us 2is far from the only game to have seen its Metacritic user score take a hit shortly after release. In October 2019,Call of Duty: Modern Warfarewas also review bombedwith many of the negative reviews citing the game’s portrayal of Russians as the antagonists as the reason. These reviews also criticized the game as being American propaganda.
In this case, the negative user reviews seemed to have been published and were reported on October 28, a full three days afterCall of Duty: Modern Warfare’s release. This means that a 36-hour waiting period is unlikely to have had any effect on the game’s early user score. Other games to have beenreview bombed areDeath Stranding, which was criticized as being a “walking simulator” by some Metacritic users, andAstral Chain, which was criticized for being a Nintendo Switch exclusive.
Another idea is to bar gamers from posting a review of a game until they’ve hit a playtime threshold. If a game takes around 40 hours to complete by the developer’s own tests, then a Metacritic user may have to have played the game for a quarter of that, or 10 hours, before they can publish a review. This also has its issues as some games, likeGhost of Tsushima, can take much longer to completeif players choose to look for every collectible, and gamers may not want to spend much time in a game if they truly find it unenjoyable.
Metacritic isn’t the only platform that has faced the issue of review bombs. In 2019, Steam rolled out a new feature to tackle review bombs, though this has only partly worked. It’s unclear what will work, but those looking for better critiques, that have been qualified, want the industry to do more.
