Out of all the amazing,influential technologiespresent within theStar Trekfranchise, one of themost impressive is the replicators. Their ability to conjure almost anything with a simple command has the possibility to end world hunger in the blink of an eye. It can create any tool needed for any task without having to rummage around in endless toolboxes. They can even create material possessions such as clothing or furniture.
However, every piece of technology, no matter how remarkabe, has its constraints. While they may appear limitless, there are in fact a number of things that a replicator can not do. These are the biggest limitations of replicator technology, as shown in theStar Trekshows and movies.
RELATED:Star Trek: Exploring Klingon’s Unique Warp Technology
The first is their inability to create Dilithium crystals, the necessary ingredient forall warp travelin the galaxy (especially if abiding by whatDiscoverypreaches). Replicating Dilithium goes against the fundamentals of how this technology works. A replicator does not simply magic up the things it produces. Rather, it takes energy and reconfigures it on a cellular level into whatever is requested. Different things take different amounts of energy based on their complexity. An apple, for example, is fairly simple on an atomic level. Meanwhile, a gold necklace is far more complicated, requiring not just a reconfiguration of atoms but various forms of fusion to combine them. Replicators can create a lot of difficult things, but Dilithium is so complex that there would not be enough power to create it.
The exception might be the use of Dilithium itself to create Dilithium, directly plugging the replicator into the warp core power. However, it is established that replicators still abide by the second law of thermodynamics: As energy is transferred, some will always be wasted. As such, energy will always be lost in the process of replication, no matter how much power is pumped in. This means that even if there was a way to use Dilithium to replicate more Dilithium, the user would end up getting far less than was used up in the process. Attempting to replicate Dilithum would be a waste of time.
This leads on to the second limitation for replicators: that of sustainable food sources. It’s true that the use ofthese nifty machines would easily eradicate world hunger, but not Quadrant-wide hunger. The Federation still relies on naturally grown food to support its massive population. The amount of energy required to produce ample food for everyone would be far too much to sustainably support. It could be possible, via growing something in abundance, converting that into energy, and using said energy to power replicators en-mass. However, it’s much less practical when there are hundreds of vegetation-supporting planets all primed to be able to grow food. On a side note, though, replicators are still great forvegans and vegetariansin this regard. The technology can replicate animal products without ethical issue, converting vegetation into replicated meat.
The next limitation is that a replicator, despite appearances, can only create inanimate matter. There is no way one could be used to create life. Now, life is an interesting topic in this regard, as it is specifically different from organic matter. A vegetable is different from a living, breathing being. The difference is that inanimate things can be replicated by using cellular and molecular reconstruction, taking energy and reassembling it to appear similar, if not identical, to the real thing. What they struggle to do, however, is anything on the quantum level. This is necessary for things relying on neural patterns or pathways to function and ‘live.’ While this is impossible for the majority of replicators, it’s not actually unfeasible. The biggest issue is that of storage potential. Most things take up little to no memory to replicate, their patterns being relatively simple. However, to replicate anything on the quantum level would be so complex that there wouldn’t be enough storage to contain that much information.
It’s not impossible, however, and already these devices started to sneak into canon.TNGfeatured a special replicator that was able to create and replaceWorf’s spine’s spine after a terrible accident. However, this is where the technology seems to have reached its current limit, as it cannot create functional body parts yet. If they struggle to do, this it’s no wonder that the idea of creating sentient life is deep into the realms of impossibility, even with the technology available to those in the 24th and onward centuries. Even without the use of replicators, sentience and ‘life’ is hard to create. Characters such as Data and his evil twin Lore are unique.
Replicators seem to present a duality within theStar Trekuniverse. On one hand, they are a prime example of possible future technologies. Yet at the same time, they show that there are still massive limitations even to such advanced minds found within the Federation. Even in the far future, there are still some things humanity cannot yet do.
